An Australian gym fired a trainer for still running with its old run club. A tribunal has now ruled the firing unfair, and the gym owes him six weeks' pay.
The case turned on one text message. If you've ever cut a class with a quick note to the instructor, this is worth five minutes.
What happened
The trainer worked at Next Generation Clubs Australia, known as Next Gen, from November 2019. He was a casual employee (paid by the hour, with no guaranteed shifts), working as a personal trainer, floor attendant and group fitness instructor. He coached the club's Run Club twice a week.
In 2025 the gym capped Run Club at six people to free up treadmills. At that size, it decided the class no longer paid its way.
On March 6, 2026, the group fitness coordinator sent him a message. Run Club would leave the timetable, with no more sessions from March 23. He should tell members, and "set up a different option for them if they want to go down that track."
The members kept meeting anyway. One long-standing member told the tribunal the group invited him along, and that he ran "as a member rather than acting as its paid trainer." On April 16, the general manager saw him leading about six members on the treadmills, with a timer on the TV screens. He was dismissed on April 26.
Why did the gym lose the case?
The gym said it gave a clear instruction and he ignored it. Australia's Fair Work Commission disagreed. Deputy President Dean said he was "not satisfied that the 6 March message was unambiguous," because the same text invited the trainer to set up another option for members. At best, he found, it was a misunderstanding. With no valid reason to fire him, the dismissal was unfair. The gym's process was fine. It told him why and let him respond. That didn't save it. The wording did the damage.
The decision is [2026] FWC 4445, handed down on November 17. OnNotice, which covers Australian workplace law, has a full summary.
Two readings of the same text
| What the gym said | What the trainer said | What the Commission found | |
|---|---|---|---|
| The March 6 text | A clear order to stop Run Club | It ended Run Club as a paid, scheduled class | Not clear enough, because it invited "a different option" |
| The April sessions | Unauthorised sessions on gym equipment | Informal runs he joined as a member, never hidden | A misunderstanding at best |
| The firing | A fair process | No chance to stop before he was let go | The process was sound, but there was no valid reason |
The members' part of the story
Here's what stuck with us. The gym looked at Run Club and saw six treadmills it wanted back. The members saw a habit they weren't ready to give up. So they kept it going on their own, and invited their coach.
That's what a community does when you cut its ritual. It doesn't always leave quietly. Run clubs are one of the fastest-growing formats around. They grew 3.5 times last year, and brands now run their own to win customers.
Before you cut one, ask who's in it, how long they've been coming, and where they'll go next.
What to do if you're cutting a class
This is an Australian case under Australian law, and none of this is legal advice. But the lessons travel.
Write the instruction like you mean it. Say what is ending, from when, and what isn't allowed after that. Keep a stop order separate from an invitation. "Set up a different option" sounds friendly. It also gave the trainer room to read it his way.
Say what counts as work. If staff can't coach members on your floor outside the timetable, say so. If they can join a group as a member, say that too.
Give people a chance to fix it. The trainer stopped as soon as management raised it. A clear warning first would have given the gym a clear instruction to point to.
Plan the members' next step. If the class goes, offer them something real, like a new time, a different format or a member-led group you're happy to host. Good trainers are hard enough to keep, as our look at the trainer shortage found. Losing a coach of six years, and his regulars, over one text is the worst version.
Cut the class if you need to. Just make sure the message says exactly what you mean.