A UK gym has been fined for leaving its joining fee out of the price. Now a much bigger chain is facing the same questions.
On September 29, the UK's competition watchdog, the CMA, fined Gold's Gym (UK) £45,000. The company runs four Gold's Gym franchise clubs in London. The CMA found it didn't include the joining fee in the total price shown for its annual and Direct Debit memberships. Where the fee did appear, it was easy to miss. The gym also has to refund 726 members. The CMA announced the fine on October 14.
Then on November 17, it opened an investigation into Bannatyne Health Club. The concern is similar: joining fees and charges to use facilities that showed up later in sign-up, instead of in the first price people saw. Nothing has been proven. The CMA says no finding has been made.
We think this points somewhere bigger. Once the joining fee has to sit in the headline price, a lot of gyms will find it isn't worth keeping.
What did Gold's Gym UK do wrong?
The CMA found that Gold's Gym UK left its joining fee out of the total price people saw for its annual and Direct Debit memberships. Where the fee was shown, it was shown in a way people were unlikely to notice. Under UK law since April 2025, any fee a customer has to pay must be in the price from the start. The gym admitted the breach and settled, which cut its fine by 40%. It now refunds each affected member £50 or £10, depending on the membership they bought.
The law behind it
The rule comes from the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act. Since April 2025 it has let the CMA fine a business directly, without going to court first. The target here is drip pricing (when a fee you have to pay is added after the headline price).
In its first year with those powers, the CMA opened cases against 23 businesses, it says. Gyms are one of the areas it names. Its consumer protection director, Emma Cochrane, said people should be able to compare prices "whether that's planning a hard-earned holiday or picking the right gym membership."
Two gym cases, side by side
| Gold's Gym (UK) | Bannatyne Health Club | |
|---|---|---|
| Case opened | Nov 17, 2025 | Nov 17, 2026 |
| The concern | Joining fee left out of the total price | Joining fees and facility charges added later in sign-up |
| Status | Settled. Fined Sep 29, 2026 | Open. The CMA is gathering evidence |
| Outcome | £45,000 fine and refunds to 726 members | No finding yet |
Why we think joining fees are on the way out
A joining fee does two jobs. It brings in cash on day one. And it lets you advertise a monthly price that's lower than what a new member really pays in year one.
This law takes away the second job. If the fee has to sit inside the first price people see, your low monthly number stops looking low. You're left with a fee that makes your offer look pricier than the gym down the road that doesn't charge one.
Plenty of gyms already treat the fee that way. It gets waived for January, for a referral, or for anyone who asks at the front desk. Once it has to be shown up front, it gets harder to justify.
So we expect more gyms to drop it, or fold it into a slightly higher monthly price. That's our read, not a CMA finding. The CMA hasn't banned joining fees. It wants them shown clearly from the start.
A clear price can still go up. The Gym Group raised its prices 5% and still added members. And if you're rethinking your price from scratch, our guide to pricing a boutique studio walks through setting a monthly number that stands on its own.
Does this reach US gyms?
Not this law. But the same idea is already law in some states. California's SB 478, in force since July 2024, bans advertising a price that leaves out mandatory fees, for most businesses. If you sell memberships in California, a mandatory joining or annual fee that only shows up at checkout is the kind of thing it targets. Check with a lawyer for your state.
What to do this week
Open your own sign-up page on your phone. Buy a membership the way a stranger would. Write down the first price you see, then the price you actually pay. If those two numbers are different, you have the same problem these gyms do.
Then check your ads, your front desk script and your promo emails. The first price anywhere should be the full price.
Then ask the bigger question. If the joining fee has to be in plain sight, is it still earning its keep? For a lot of gyms, the honest answer will be no.